Before reading a label, check the rounding

Original data-literacy handout by ECRtest. Numbers and people in this example are fictional.

A demonstration chart draws a dividing line at 3.00. Two fictional points on one axis are 2.98 and 3.02. The labels underneath both dots say 3.0 because that part of the chart shows only one decimal place.

PointExact coordinate in the exampleRounded label
A2.983.0
B3.023.0

Three-minute practice

  1. If you saw only the labels, could you tell which side of the line each point is on?
  2. Once you see the exact coordinates, what is the difference between the two dots?
  3. Write a chart description that does not turn the small difference into a claim about the people.

Check: The rounded labels are identical. The original coordinates are on opposite sides and only 0.04 apart. A clear description is: “In this example, the dots straddle the line and are very close.” The dividing line and figures here are for practice, not a real scoring rule.

To see why precise coordinates and a category name answer different questions, read the ECRtest guide to interpreting a result.