BMR Formulas: Why Two Calculators Give You Different Numbers

BMR Formulas: Why Two Calculators Give You Different Numbers

Type your age, height, weight and sex into two basal metabolic rate (BMR) calculators and you may get answers that differ by 100–200 calories a day. Neither is necessarily wrong. The disagreement comes from the fact that there is no single BMR formula — there are several, each built on a different dataset and each with its own assumptions.

What BMR actually is

Basal metabolic rate is the energy your body burns at rest to keep essential functions going — breathing, circulation, cell maintenance. It is usually expressed as calories per day and represents the largest share of most people's daily energy expenditure.

Because it cannot be measured directly outside a lab, BMR is estimated from body measurements and demographic variables. Every estimation formula is a statistical model, and different models fit different populations better.

The two common formulas

The Mifflin-St Jeor equation (developed in 1990) is widely used today:

  • Men: BMR = 10×weight(kg) + 6.25×height(cm) − 5×age + 5
  • Women: BMR = 10×weight(kg) + 6.25×height(cm) − 5×age − 161

The older Harris-Benedict equation (1919, revised in 1984) uses different coefficients:

  • Men: BMR = 88.36 + 13.4×weight + 4.8×height − 5.7×age
  • Women: BMR = 447.6 + 9.25×weight + 3.1×height − 4.3×age

Worked example

Take a 30-year-old woman, 165 cm tall, weighing 60 kg.

Mifflin-St Jeor: 10(60) + 6.25(165) − 5(30) − 161 = 600 + 1031 − 150 − 161 = 1320 kcal/day.

Harris-Benedict (revised): 447.6 + 9.25(60) + 3.1(165) − 4.3(30) = 447.6 + 555 + 511.5 − 129 = 1385 kcal/day.

That is a difference of about 65 calories — modest, but enough to shift a carefully planned calorie target. For other body types the gap can be larger.

Why the difference matters

Mifflin-St Jeor was developed on a more modern, broader dataset and generally performs better for today's populations, which is why many health organizations prefer it. Harris-Benedict is older and tends to overestimate for some groups. Neither accounts for body composition: two people of the same weight and height but different muscle mass have different BMRs, and neither formula knows the difference.

Practical rules

  1. Pick one formula and stick with it — consistency matters more than which one.
  2. Treat the result as an estimate with a margin of error, not a precise value.
  3. Adjust based on real-world results (weight trend over weeks) rather than chasing the "perfect" formula.
  4. Multiply BMR by an activity factor to estimate total daily energy needs.

A tool that shows the formula

When you want to compute BMR with the formula visible rather than hidden, the BMR calculator at Miryori runs in the browser and shows the equation and inputs behind the result. Nothing is uploaded.


Disclosure: The author leads content at Miryori, the free calculator suite linked above. Figures are estimates, not medical advice.