Individual coaching or a team workshop: where should a workplace issue begin?

When a workplace issue affects a whole team, a workshop may seem like the obvious answer. When one person raises it, individual coaching may seem more appropriate. The better starting point depends on what needs to change and who has the power to change it.

Start with a concrete situation

“Communication is poor” describes a concern, but it does not tell you what to work on. Name a recent situation instead. Perhaps decisions are made in a meeting but reopened afterwards. Perhaps a new manager is unsure when to delegate. Perhaps colleagues avoid saying when a deadline is unrealistic. These situations can look similar from a distance and require different conversations.

Ask who experiences the issue, who can change the conditions, and what evidence would show improvement. If the problem is an unclear decision process shared by the whole team, a group conversation may be useful. If one leader wants to examine how they respond under pressure, private coaching may be a better place to begin.

When individual coaching helps

Coaching gives a person room to think through their choices and assumptions. A manager can explore a difficult conversation, practise framing a decision or consider how their behaviour affects others. The discussion can include sensitive details that would be inappropriate for a group workshop. But one person's coaching cannot substitute for a team-wide agreement or a structural decision by the organisation.

When a workshop helps

A workshop can bring people together to examine a shared challenge and agree on what they will do differently. It works best when the purpose is specific, the right people are present and the sponsor is willing to act on what emerges. A one-off session cannot repair an unresolved conflict or change incentives on its own. Plan what happens after the workshop: who owns the next steps, when the team will review them and how people can raise concerns.

Sometimes the sequence matters

One or two individual conversations may help a sponsor clarify the real question before inviting a team into a workshop. In another situation, a workshop may reveal that some leaders need separate support. The formats can complement each other, but each should have its own purpose and a realistic expectation of what it can achieve.

Edengard describes its workshops for organisations and individual coaching online. If you are deciding which format fits your workplace situation, contact Tamara Georgiadou with a short description of the issue.